Taylors and Company 1873 Gunfighter .357 Magnum 5.50″

The Taylors and Company 1873 Gunfighter .357 Magnum 5.50″ is a single-action revolver that brings the Old West to life with modern metallurgy and a hard-hitting caliber. Forged with a color case-hardened steel frame, blued barrel and cylinder, and an Army-size walnut grip, this six-shooter is built for sport, recreational shooting, and serious collecting. Chambered for .357 Magnum (also feeds .38 Special), it delivers the iconic 1873 profile with a 5.50-inch barrel that balances pointability and power. Per manufacturer specs, this is a faithful reproduction of the legendary Peacemaker, tuned for today’s shooter.

Manufacturer	Taylors and Company
Model	1873 Gunfighter
Material	Forged color case-hardened steel frame, blued steel barrel and cylinder
Compatibility	.357 Magnum / .38 Special
Finish	Color case-hardened frame, blued barrel and cylinder
Weight	Approx. 40 oz (per manufacturer specs)
Condition	New

Key Features

• Forged Color Case-Hardened Frame — Why it matters: This traditional treatment not only looks like a museum piece but also provides a durable, corrosion-resistant surface that stands up to heavy use at the range or in the field.
• 5.50-Inch Barrel — Why it matters: The longer sight radius gives you improved accuracy for target work and plinking, while still being compact enough for holster carry at cowboy action matches.
• Army-Size Walnut Grip — Why it matters: Larger than standard 1873 grips, this fills your hand for a more secure hold, reducing felt recoil from .357 Magnum loads and keeping you on target faster.
• Fixed Blade Front Sight with Frame Notch Rear — Why it matters: This period-correct sight setup is fast to acquire and rugged — no snagging, no adjustment needed, just point and shoot like the cowboys did.
• 6-Round Cylinder in .357 Magnum — Why it matters: You get the versatility to shoot both .357 Magnum for maximum energy and .38 Special for cheap, soft-recoiling practice, all in one revolver.

Who It’s For

This revolver is for the collector who wants an authentic 1873 pattern with modern chambering, the cowboy action shooter who demands reliability and correct period styling, and the recreational shooter who appreciates the feel of a single-action sixgun. If you love gun shows, old Westerns, and the tangible history of a forged steel frame, this is your wheelhouse.

Pros & Cons

Pros: Authentic color case-hardening and blued finish; .357 Magnum power with .38 Special compatibility; larger grip improves control; solid steel construction; competitive price for a forged-frame 1873.

Cons: Fixed sights limit adjustment for windage/elevation; single-action only means slower follow-up shots; some shooters may prefer a 4.75″ barrel for faster draw — the 5.50″ is a sweet spot but not for everyone.

Comparison

Feature	Taylors 1873 Gunfighter .357	Uberti 1873 Cattleman .357	Ruger New Vaquero .357
Frame Material	Forged color case-hardened steel	Forged case-hardened steel	Investment cast stainless or blued steel
Barrel Length	5.50″	4.75″, 5.5″, 7.5″	4.62″, 5.5″
Grip	Army-size walnut	Standard walnut	Hard rubber or walnut
Weight	~40 oz	~38 oz	~36 oz
Price	$659.60	$625–$700	$750–$850
Notes	Larger grip for better control; fixed sights	Widely available; traditional grip	Transfer bar safety; adjustable rear sight on some models

FAQ

Can I shoot .38 Special in this revolver?

Yes, the Taylors and Company 1873 Gunfighter is chambered for .357 Magnum and is fully compatible with .38 Special ammunition. This lets you practice with cheaper, lower-recoil loads and step up to .357 Magnum when you want full power.

Is this a faithful reproduction of the Colt 1873?

It follows the classic 1873 pattern with a forged, color case-hardened steel frame, blued barrel and cylinder, and fixed sights. It’s a modern production piece by Taylors and Company, built to the same specifications as the original Peacemaker but chambered for the more powerful .357 Magnum.

What is the barrel length and sight radius?

The barrel is 5.50 inches, which gives you a longer sight radius than the 4.75″ models, improving accuracy for target shooting. The fixed blade front sight and frame notch rear are period-correct and durable.

Is this revolver safe for modern .357 Magnum loads?

Yes, per manufacturer specs, the forged steel frame and cylinder are heat-treated to handle modern .357 Magnum pressures. Always use factory ammunition within SAAMI specifications.

Does it come with a manual or warranty?

Yes, the revolver includes a user manual and is covered by Taylors and Company’s warranty against defects in materials and workmanship. Check with your dealer for specific warranty terms.

✓ Nationwide delivery (all 50 states) via FFL dealer
✓ Ships 1-2 business days after FFL verification
✓ 30-day returns on unfired, undamaged items
✓ Secure checkout with encrypted payment processing

Looking for more single-action revolvers? Browse our Revolvers and Cowboy Action Shooting Gear collections.

Last updated: April 2026